We run creator campaigns on X for crypto projects. A client writes the brief and approves every creator. We do the rest: find the creators, reach out, coordinate posts, track results.

It works. Our campaign for Prophet, a new prediction market, ran 18 creators across four waves, published 72 posts at a $9.86 CPM, and Prophet credited it with more than 2,000 new users.

But a managed campaign is not the right first move for every team. We turn down or redirect some requests because the project would get more from running a small test itself. Here is how we decide.

The short answer

Your situation

What we'd suggest

No product live yet, or no way to count sign-ups

Wait. Fix tracking first

Budget for 5–10 posts

Run it yourself

You've never run a KOL test and want to learn what works

Run a small test yourself

You have a list from an agency and want a second opinion

Check the list yourself

You need 15+ creators over several weeks and nobody on the team has time

Managed campaign

You ran a test, know what converts, and want to scale it

Managed campaign

When you shouldn't hire us

1. You can't measure what happens after the post. If your product has no referral codes, no UTM tracking and no way to see who signed up from where, any campaign will end in a debate about whether it worked. A managed campaign makes that debate more expensive. Set up tracking first. One link per creator is enough to start.

2. Your budget covers a handful of posts. In our survey of 1,051 crypto creators on X, the median asking price for one post was $50 for accounts with 1K–10K followers and $100 for 10K–25K. At those prices, five to ten posts is a few hundred dollars. Paying a team to coordinate that makes no sense. You can message five creators yourself in an afternoon.

3. You don't know yet what message works. The first campaign is a test of the offer as much as of the creators. In the Prophet campaign, the wave that gave new users $5 in free trading credit beat the other three by a wide margin. You learn that kind of thing faster with three creators and two versions of the message than with thirty creators and one.

4. Your product isn't ready for traffic. If onboarding takes ten steps or the app breaks on mobile, creators will send people into a wall. No creator selection fixes that.

5. Someone on your team already does this well. If you have a KOL manager with good taste and a spreadsheet, you may not need an agency. You may need better data on which creators have a real audience. That is a tool problem, not a people problem.

When a managed campaign is worth it

You need scale and nobody has the time. A campaign with 15–20 creators and three or four waves means hundreds of messages, drafts to approve, posting schedules, payment and follow-up. For a team of three, that is a part-time job for weeks.

You need creators you can't reach. Many good mid-size creators ignore cold DMs from unknown projects. We work with an existing creator base, so the first conversation is easier.

You want to adjust between waves. In the Prophet campaign we changed the roster between waves to raise audience fit and cut CPM without losing reach. Engagement rates across creators ranged from above 12% to under 1% at similar prices. Seeing that gap and acting on it is most of the work.

You've already tested. If you ran a small campaign yourself and know which message converts, a managed campaign is how you scale it without hiring.

If you're running it yourself

The hard part is not sending DMs. It's picking creators whose followers are real and care about your niche. Follower count tells you little about that.

We built a tool for exactly this step. Oznaka (oznaka.ai), built by Wallchain, finds and vets crypto creators on X by organic reach, organic replies, niche match and price. It's the same kind of selection we use in our own campaigns, available as self-serve.

For a side-by-side breakdown of the four options — marketplace, agency, in-house with a spreadsheet, in-house with a data tool — with cost, time and bot risk for each, see crypto KOL marketplace vs agency vs in-house.

FAQ

Should an early-stage crypto project pay influencers before it has organic traction?
Pay for a small test, not a big campaign. Five to ten creators with one tracked link each will show whether the message lands. If nobody signs up, a bigger campaign won't fix it.

Our KOL manager picks creators from experience and a Google Sheet. Is that enough?
It works until the list grows past 20–30 names or you start paying for accounts you've never checked. At that point you need data on real reach and real replies, not more columns in the sheet.

How do I know if an agency's creator list is any good?
Check each account for organic replies, real impressions and how much of the audience follows projects in your niche. A list where half the accounts fail that check is common.

Two ways to start

If you want to run it yourself, search and vet creators in Oznaka. There's a free plan.

If you'd rather have it done for you, Wallchain Select runs the campaign end to end. [SK: contact link] — tell us your goal and budget, and we'll say honestly whether a managed campaign makes sense.